States diverge on policies amid federal health debates
As federal health leaders debate the science over what's best for American health, some states are crafting their own health laws, creating a patchwork of policies with potential health risks.
As federal health leaders debate the science over what's best for American health, some states are crafting their own health laws, creating a patchwork of policies with potential health risks.
As federal health leaders debate the science over what's best for American health, some states are crafting their own health laws, creating a patchwork of policies with potential health risks.
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. faced intense criticism before Congress this week over recent changes to federal vaccine policies and staffing shakeups in top health agencies.
"Finally, we have an administration that is taking action," Kennedy said while testifying before lawmakers on the Senate Finance Committee Thursday.
The changes have led to pushback from over 1,000 current and former workers who signed calling for Kennedy's resignation.
"There have been policies coming top down that are getting in the way of us putting out good science that are slowing us down," Jenna Norton, a NIH employee who signed the letter, said. "I do not understand how spreading disinformation is going to help us rebuild Americans' trust."
The conflict at the federal level is prompting some states to take action this week.
In Florida, Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo announced plans to phase out childhood vaccine mandates.
Meanwhile, leaders in Massachusetts promised insurance coverage for vaccines recommended at the state level, regardless of federal policy.
Pennsylvania and New York are moving in a similar direction as Massachusetts, making vaccines widely accessible even if the federal government does not recommend them.
Even more states on the West Coast, like California, Oregon, and Washington, are forming their own health alliance to uphold what they call "scientific integrity" in opposition to the Trump administration's policies. Conversely, West Virginia's governor signed an order allowing parents to claim religious exemptions for school vaccine requirements.
But doctors worry that varying state-by-state policies could lead to a public health crisis.
"Changes in policy like this that happen in one state or in one jurisdiction have potential ramifications everywhere," Dr. Christina Johns, a pediatrician, said. "People know and don't know that they are sick, and then they travel, and so the potential for rapid transmission beyond state lines is extensive."
Doctors say federal health guidelines and mandates provide states with a unified, science-based roadmap to protect the general population from outbreaks. They also ensure an "equitable and stable" healthcare system. According to Johns, the mandates have become victims of their own success — eradicating diseases for so long that people may have forgotten their importance.
As states pursue their own health policy paths, experts emphasize the importance of having direct conversations with doctors to determine the best health practices.
Watch the latest on vaccine guidelines: